Skip to content
BlackBadger

Custom software. Payback calculator

Is custom software worth it for your company?

Pick the project management, CRM or ERP tools you pay for and the plan you are on. Prices come from each vendor's own pricing page. You will see what those tools cost over five years, what a custom build would typically cost, and how fast it pays for itself.

Prices checked November 16, 2026.

What you pay for today

One card per tool. Pick the tool and plan and the list price fills in. Change it if your invoice says otherwise.

Billed

Above 25 users, Smartsheet only sells Enterprise or higher. Smartsheet publishes no Enterprise price, so this is the typical price our clients have been quoted, billed yearly only. Change it to yours.

* Does not factor in any discount your company may have negotiated.

Want the full picture? The advanced version adds setup and support costs, how long your team waits on changes, your own quote and a five-year chart.

How the numbers are worked out
  • Each tool costs users times the plan's price per user, every month, at the yearly or monthly rate you pick. Platform fees that do not depend on users are added as they are billed.
  • Above 25 users, vendors sell only their enterprise plans, so the calculator moves you there. Enterprise plans bill yearly.
  • Each year the price rises by the increase you set and the user count grows by the growth you set. Custom software has no per-user fee, so growth costs nothing there.
  • The typical build cost comes from what we charge. Between 25 and 50 users it is about one year of your licenses, from $45,000 to $85,000. Bigger accounts are priced below one year of licenses, so the build pays for itself inside a year. It is a guide drawn from past projects, not a promised price, because the real cost depends heavily on features. A quote you enter replaces the estimate.
  • Payback is the first month in which what you stop paying the platforms, less the cost of running the custom app, covers the build.
  • List prices were checked against each vendor's pricing page on November 16, 2026. Plans with no published price use a typical figure from our client quotes or a named partner, and say which.

The short answer

When does custom software pay for itself?

It comes down to how many people you license and what each seat costs. Past 25 seats you are on an enterprise plan whether you want one or not, and the yearly bill is usually larger than a build that ends it. These are the bands our past projects fall into.

Company sizeTypical custom buildUsual payback
Under 25 usersFrom $45,000Often two years or more, so the platforms usually stay cheaper
25 to 50 usersAbout one year of licenses, $45,000 to $85,000One to two years
Over 50 users, or over $85,000 a year in licensesBelow one year of licensesInside a year

Estimates based on past projects, not quoted prices. The real cost depends heavily on the features you need. Running the finished app usually costs a few hundred dollars a month, with no charge per user.

Beyond the license

What does the calculator count that a price list does not?

Seats are only part of the bill. Platform fees that do not depend on users, required onboarding, partner and admin support, and the yearly price increase all add up, and the advanced version lets you put in your own numbers for each.

It also counts time. On a platform, a new field or report waits for an admin, a consultant or the vendor's roadmap, often for a week or more. On software you own, most changes we make are done within 24 hours, bigger ones take 2 to 5 business days, and very large ones a week or two.

Questions

What do people ask about the payback math?

When does custom software pay for itself?

When what you stop paying your platforms each year covers the build quickly. Between 25 and 50 users a build usually costs about one year of licenses, so it pays back in one to two years. Above 50 users, or past about $85,000 a year in licenses, it usually pays back inside a year. Under 25 users the platforms usually stay cheaper, and we will tell you so.

Why does the calculator move me to an enterprise plan?

Because the vendors do. Once an account passes 25 or 30 seats, Smartsheet, monday.com, Wrike, ClickUp, Asana, Salesforce and most of the others will not sell anything below their enterprise plan, and enterprise plans bill yearly. Enterprise prices are not published, so the calculator uses the typical price our clients have been quoted and marks it with an asterisk.

Is the build cost a quote?

No. It is an estimate based on past projects of a similar size, and the real cost depends heavily on the features you need. A fixed quote comes after a scoping call, and you can type it into the advanced version to see your own payback.

What does running custom software cost after it is built?

Hosting, monitoring and support for an app you own usually run a few hundred dollars a month, and that figure does not grow when you add users. The calculator uses $400 a month, and you can change it in the advanced version.

Where do the platform prices come from?

From each vendor's own pricing page, checked on November 16, 2026, and linked from every tool card and in the list below. ERPs mostly publish nothing, so those figures come from named partners, implementers and deal data, and each card says which. One NetSuite figure is matched to a five-user account we replaced, which was paying $55,188 a year.

Want a real number instead of an estimate?

Book a strategy call, or send a short note about the tools you pay for and what they do for you. If staying on your platform is the right answer, you will hear that first.

We primarily work with businesses with 50+ employees. The form is open to everyone.

No newsletter, no drip sequence. One reply from a person.